Growth
Winning a Retained Search Without a Tender: Bid Win #18
A partner agency won a retained search with xrecruiter's bid and tender team and no tender in sight. How the pitch was won and how private terms get agreed.
A partner agency has won a retained search with an international business setting up in Australia, and xrecruiter's bid and tender team wrote the pitch that won it. It is a new win, for one senior leadership role, and it came from a private sector pitch rather than a panel or a public tender. In brief: the partner brought the network and the recruiting, and the team started the written offer on the afternoon of the first meeting. Three months later that offer became a retained search.
Pitches still waiting on an answer
Two more pitches written with partner agencies are out with private sector buyers. Neither has an answer yet, and neither carries a value we can publish.
What made this one hard
The buyer was setting up in a new market, and its own hiring had stalled. That sounds like an open door. It is also the moment a buyer is most careful about who it lets in, because a second false start costs it months.
There was no tender document to answer. The buyer published no criteria and no closing date. All the partner had was a meeting, a sense of what the business needed, and very little time before the buyer's attention moved somewhere else.
What got it over the line
Our read, which the buyer has not confirmed: two things carried it.
- The partner's network in the buyer's sector. The partner already knew the people a business like this would want to meet, and the written offer could show that rather than claim it.
- A flexible offer. The pitch gave the buyer a choice between an exclusive and a retained arrangement, so it could pick the level of commitment it was ready for.
How the bid and tender team helped, in order: it started on the written offer the same afternoon the partner met the buyer. It built the document around the buyer's launch in Australia, and the first version also covered other launch roles. When the buyer came back months later wanting one senior hire, the team reworked the whole document into a retained offer. The role, the commercial terms and the terms of business were all updated, and the file was cut down to something easy to send.
What would have stopped the agency bidding alone
The report says no gate, and that is worth taking at face value. This buyer set no insurance threshold, panel entry rule or financial screen before choosing a search firm. Nothing formal stood in the way.
What stands in the way on a deal like this is time. A one desk agency is recruiting all day. Writing a tailored pitch the same afternoon, then rebuilding it from scratch when the brief changes, is the work that slips. Meanwhile the partner kept doing the part only the partner could do, which was every point of contact with the buyer.
What the evaluators weighted, and how we know
We know only from the partner's own meeting, so this is our read rather than a debrief. At that meeting, the buyer's leadership said plainly what they wanted: a partner who could fill roles the business had already struggled to fill on its own.
That set the job for the pitch: show the buyer that the partner could reach people its own search had not. This buyer had no published criteria to score against. It decided whether it believed the partner.
What we see
What we see on private sector pitches is that the first written offer often decides who stays in the conversation. Work on this one started on the afternoon of the meeting. Three months passed before the buyer came back, and when it did, it came back to the partner.
We also see the brief change between the first written offer and the signed one. Here it narrowed from a set of launch roles to one senior hire. An agency that treats the first version as finished loses that second round to whoever answers faster.
Methodology: the story on this page comes from the bid win report our bid and tender team filed after the award, with every name removed. The mechanism sections link to government pages.
Work actually won through bids is tracked on one register line, $13.5M work won for partner agencies through bids, and this retained search adds a private sector win to it.
How a retained search pitch turns into a contract
A retained search is an engagement where a buyer commits to one agency for a role before a candidate is found, instead of paying only on placement. The buyer gets one firm working the market on its behalf, and the agency gets paid for the search itself.
Private buyers have no duty to tender. Government buyers work differently. The Commonwealth's guide to identifying opportunities to sell to government describes a limited tender, where the buyer approaches invited suppliers directly, alongside open tenders and panels. A private pitch works like a limited tender with no rules attached: the buyer invites, compares and decides on its own terms.
Terms of business are the written contract between the agency and the buyer. Government guidance on how to prepare a contract says a written agreement should cover the work, the payment amount and timing, when the job is finished and how disputes are handled. Those are the same parts a search agreement needs.
A variation is a change to the agreed terms. The same guidance says a change can be agreed out loud but should be written down and signed by both sides. When this buyer asked for a small change, that is what happened.
Before agreeing to any requested change, read it. The advice on how to negotiate a contract is not to sign a clause you are unsure of in the hope of fixing it later, because signed terms bind you.
A standard form contract is one party's own document, offered with little room to negotiate. Your terms of business are usually one. The guide to types of contracts says either side can still negotiate before signing. Small businesses are protected from unfair terms in standard form contracts, and the ACCC notes that using such terms now attracts penalties rather than only being voided by a court.
The practical points for a small agency:
- Write the first offer while the meeting is still fresh.
- Keep it easy to rebuild, for example with the role, the terms and the candidate approach in separate sections, because the brief will change.
- Treat your terms of business as part of the offer, not an attachment.
- Put every agreed change in writing.
If you are weighing whether you could run a desk like this under your own name, start with how to know if you are ready to go out on your own. Government work runs on a different track, set out in how small recruitment agencies get onto government panels. A council panel win from the same series is in bid win 17, an SA council recruitment panel.
Frequently asked questions
What is a retained search?
A retained search is an engagement where the buyer commits to one agency for a role before any candidate is found. The agency works the market on the buyer's behalf, which suits a senior or hard to fill role, such as a leadership hire for a business entering a new market. The terms of business set out how the work runs.
Does a private company have to run a tender to hire an agency?
No. Government buyers follow procurement rules that set out open tenders, limited tenders and panels. A private business can invite whoever it likes, compare pitches however it likes, and decide on its own. That makes speed and relationships matter more than formal scoring against published criteria.
Can a buyer change your terms of business?
A buyer can ask, and either side can negotiate terms before signing, even on a standard form document. Read any requested change before you agree to it. Once agreed, put the variation in writing and have both parties sign it, so the contract still records what you both meant.
Are an agency's terms of business covered by unfair contract terms law?
They can be. When an agency offers its own terms on a take it or leave it basis to a small business, those terms are a standard form contract. Unfair terms in that kind of contract can be declared void by a court, and using them can now attract penalties.
The next step isn't a sales call
If you want pitches like this one written for your agency, the working session is the next step. Bring your real numbers: the sectors you recruit in, the buyers you already know, and the work you would want to win. Meet the payroll lead and the bid and tender team, and stress test us the way anyone should before handing over their back office. Half the people who sit the session sign. We start four agencies a month. Nothing is public, ever.
